Rob is not asking the set to be listed, but the little blue sheet he received back from Upper Deck. He knows the set is not anything unique.

Odd, nowhere in this thread does he say that. Perhaps you spoke to him and got it clear. A blue sheet of paper with type set is not remarkable enough to be listed in my opinion.

A baseball card with his name is something that I would keep on the list though.

Fair enough...and yes, I did talk to him to clarify what he meant.

The next evolution of the site is for users to be able to add whatever they want to the list, with only they being able to see it.

no redemption card should be on the oddball list that is how the cards were optained in the first place. but lets keep the coffee mugs and watches coming.I GIVE UP!

Where is the redemption card that you speak of? You said earlier it would take you awhile to find it, where is it? There is no problem adding a redemption card if it says Juan Gonzalez on it -- let's see it.

i was not refering to the 94,but the 02 ultimate,mike was refering to.

What redemption card is this exactly? Is it on the list or is it not? If it contains juan's name or image then it belongs on the main list.

look at the 1994 collectors choice team vs team #7 with griffey&gonzalez on it. THAT is your redemption card! so now maybe the 94 send back will go on the oddball list?

Are you still asking for that blue paper to be put on the list?