possible additions thread

[adelith]

Originally Posted by knr47

Not sure if this should be added as an error, but it's kind of interesting. Ebay auction #330134058778 - Juan's name on a 2001 Upper Deck hockey player's card?

I bought it, is kind of interesting card.

[freddie]

Welcome Roberto, are you going to grace our forum by listing your mighty collection? We need more competition for the top spot.

[jjt111]

I had made an offer for just the Gonzalez card but it was declined automaticly but I certainly think the card needs to be listed in the oddball stuff as I'm sure it wasn't ran in production of any quantity.

Glad it ended up with a Juan collector.

[freddie]

We don't have any printing error type cards in the oddball section. If the terry taylor type card, or the card that is overprinted with some other card remain on the main list than that is where this card should go as well.

[jjt111]

The Terry Taylor card wasn't a one and done. It was more like the blank front cards, caught after many were releast. My opinion this card is much like the 1993 Donruss Elite card with the foot locker back that is in the oddball section. But if there is more then one then I agree with you. This isn't a blem or over print card. The card can be graded just as a Terry Taylor card was. But then I was willing to give the guy 25 for it and was brushed off, so what do I know.

[freddie]

We don't know if there is only 1. How do we know there are more than 1 or 2 of all of the other oddball printing error cards that are on the list, cards that only you or Akar have listed? This seems a lot like the 92' Bowman Keith Hernandez/Gary Clark card. The way cards are printed on sheets, it seems strange that a single card would be printed like this.

[knr47]

I can definitely see Jonas' point here, as I doubt we will see another copy of this card. However, if the card is going to be added, I would put it on the main list for two reasons: 1) We know from the seller's listing that this error exists for other players, and so if Juan appeared more than once on the printing sheet, then more than 1 copy probably does exist; and 2) We know that it was distributed in a pack. I don't know anything about that Foot Locker card, but unless someone saw it pulled, I believe there should be a reasonable amount of doubt about its origins and legitimacy. That doubt, plus the card's general weirdness, keeps the Foot Locker card in a totally unique category for me.

[nosterbor]

Roberto! welcome to the greatest Juan Gonzalez collectors site on earth! Freddy has done an outstanding job here. also Mike and Jonas for uploading photos of cards as well. welcome,welcome,welcome

[nosterbor]

i think all error cards should be listed on the main list as they are as unique as a 1/1.

[freddie]

That foot locker card is just a coupon from Foot Locker, definitely an Oddball item.