Do they need their own list?

Yes, and it should be titled "Totally Stupid Juan Gonzalez Items."

Kevin and Jonas raise valid points...there could be an oversized card, or a combination of oversized cards for every card produced out there. I kind of guessed that most of us have these things in our collections, but that they were not on the list.

Freddie might have the answer. I wouldn't mind seeing what else is out there. While I have no intention of making this the focus of my collection, it would probably be useful for cataloging purposes, if nothing else. I'm guessing that I might not be the only one here, but there's a ton of stuff on the oddball list (and on the main list as well), that I personally don't ever intend on getting...beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and some of the items just don't appeal to me. The list of "Totally Stupid Juan Gonzalez items" could vary in size and items depending on who is putting it together...I know that I'll never have a Juan Gonzalez beanie baby in my collection.

But that being said, it is nice to have a complete list of Juan stuff all in one place.

it would be nice to have two new catergories - 1) unrecognized variations - you would have the different color autos and the cards with 3 dots instead of 2 but cards like the 1990 Donruss reverse neg would stay under 1990 because it is a known variation. 2) oversized proofs or cutout cards unless it is the norm. you wouldnt put the jimmy dean or the wheaties here as it was supposed to be cut. just my thoughts

Agree!

This Is On The List